Portland's Best Old Fashioned [Updated 2025]

Each sip of an old fashioned tells a story, and after diving into the vibrant cocktail scene here, I’ve uncovered some real gems. I’ve ventured into 12 top-notch spots, sampling everything from the classic concoction to innovative twists that will make your taste buds dance.

With years of tasting and mixing under my belt, I promise you won’t find any watered-down opinions here. Whether you’re a die-hard fan of the traditional whiskey base or curious about unique infusions, I’m here to guide you to the best of the best. Let’s toast to discovering your new favorite spot in this beautiful city!

Multnomah Whiskey Library

Highlights
Welcoming atmosphere for whiskey
Knowledgeable and friendly staff
Extensive whiskey selection
Unique cocktail experience
Must-try smash burgers

Multnomah Whiskey Library: A Delightful Dive into Old Fashioneds

When you step inside Multnomah Whiskey Library, there’s an immediate sense of hospitality that envelops you like a cozy blanket. This haven for whiskey lovers is both inviting and sophisticated, making it perfect for anyone looking to sip on an exquisite old fashioned. The knowledgeable staff is passionate and eager to share their insights, helping you navigate the impressive whiskey selection.

As I settled in and perused the menu, the anticipation for my drink grew. When the old fashioned arrived, I was entranced by the way it sparkled in the ambient candlelight. This version was a delightful twist on tradition, showcasing a perfectly balanced infusion of bitters, sugar, and a hint of orange. The bourbon was exceptional, and each sip was a merry dance of flavors on my palate.

But don’t stop there! I also indulged in their must-try smash burgers, which were an unexpected yet delightful pairing. If you’re in Portland and searching for the best old fashioned, look no further than Multnomah Whiskey Library. It’s not just a drink; it’s an experience that you'll want to savor again and again.

You might also want to check out the best food trucks in Portland.

Bible Club PDX

Highlights
Charming prohibition vibe
Extensive cocktail menu
Knowledgeable bartenders
Refined and complex drinks
Perfect for unwinding

At Bible Club PDX, stepping through the door feels like entering a forbidden speakeasy full of charm and character. The prohibition-era vibe sets the perfect backdrop for indulgence, and I was eager to sample their rendition of the classic old fashioned.

As I scanned the extensive cocktail menu, it was clear that this place takes its libations seriously. The knowledgeable bartenders greeted me with an enthusiastic smile and shared their philosophy: craft cocktails made to perfection. The result? A drink that is not just a cocktail but a masterpiece.

When they finally presented my old fashioned, I was struck by its refined and complex flavors. The hint of orange paired beautifully with the rich notes of bourbon, striking a perfect balance. It was a sip that transported me to a more glamorous era, encouraging me to unwind and savor each moment.

Whether you're seeking a cozy hideaway or an evening of rich flavors, Bible Club PDX delivers. If you're on a quest for the best old fashioned in Portland, look no further; this hidden gem has captured my heart (and taste buds) in a delightful embrace!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Portland.

Scotch Lodge

Highlights
Amazing pandan old fashioned
Classy and romantic ambiance
Attentive and friendly staff
Excellent food selection
Outstanding customer service

Scotch Lodge is nothing short of a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Portland. As I stepped inside, I was immediately enveloped by its classy and romantic ambiance, which sets the perfect mood for sipping on a classic cocktail. I had high hopes for their take on the beloved old fashioned, and I was delighted to discover their amazing pandan old fashioned. This inventive twist on the traditional recipe offered a delightful depth of flavor that danced on the palate.

What truly complemented my experience was the attentive and friendly staff, who not only crafted my drink but also made me feel so warmly welcomed. Their knowledge of the menu, paired with an impressive food selection, meant that my evening was elevated beyond just a drink. I couldn't resist sampling a few bites, and they certainly didn’t disappoint!

From the meticulously crafted cocktails to the engaging atmosphere, everything at Scotch Lodge made me feel right at home. If you’re on the hunt for an enchanting experience that showcases a creative take on a classic concoction, look no further. The old fashioned here is a must-try—you're in for a delightful treat!

You might also want to check out the best stores in Portland.

Hey Love

Highlights
Cute plant decor
Delectable croissant sandwich
Convenient QR code ordering
Quick and easy cash out
Charming atmosphere

During my recent visit to Hey Love, I was instantly charmed by the cute plant decor that gives the space a warm, inviting ambiance. It's the kind of place that makes you want to settle in with a drink and enjoy the view of vibrant greenery, as you contemplate the meaning of life—or at least the meaning of a great cocktail.

Speaking of cocktails, their Old Fashioned is nothing short of a revelation. Crafted with precision, it strikes a perfect balance between bitter and sweet, showcasing rich notes of bourbon that dance delightfully on the palate. The use of freshly muddled orange and aromatic bitters adds a sophisticated twist, elevating the classic cocktail to new heights.

To top it all off, I couldn't resist pairing my drink with a delectable croissant sandwich—a match made in culinary heaven. The convenience of QR code ordering and a quick cash-out process ensures you spend less time worrying and more time sipping in this charming atmosphere.

If you're searching for the best Old Fashioned in Portland, Hey Love certainly knows how to concoct a drink that is both nostalgic and refreshing. Cheers to that!

You might also want to check out the best salad in Portland.

Driftwood Room

Highlights
Good atmosphere
A+ service
Knowledgeable bartenders
Beautifully designed space
Potentially rude staff experience

Driftwood Room provides an inviting atmosphere that immediately sets the stage for a memorable evening. Nestled within a beautifully designed space, the ambience seamlessly blends vintage charm with modern sophistication.

As I approached the bar, I was greeted by a team of knowledgeable bartenders who exuded confidence in their craft. I ordered their signature old fashioned, eager to taste what this esteemed establishment had to offer. Impressive indeed! Each sip struck a sublime balance of sweetness, bitterness, and that unmistakable warmth only bourbon can provide. The artisanal approach to muddling the fresh orange and cherry heightened the complexity of flavors, making it a truly delightful concoction.

However, it’s worth mentioning that my experience was slightly marred by an occasional lapse in service, as some staff members seemed less engaged. But when the cocktails flow like they do here, it’s easy to overlook minor inconveniences. If you're searching for an idyllic spot to enjoy one of Portland's best old fashioneds, Driftwood Room is definitely worth a visit. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just indulging in a well-deserved night out, this gem will satisfy your craving for a classic cocktail with flair.

You might also want to check out the best furniture stores in Portland.

Wilder

Highlights
Friendly and attentive staff
Great atmosphere and music
Clean open kitchen
Quick and delicious food

Review of Wilder's Old Fashioned

Stepping into Wilder felt like entering a cozy sanctuary where craft cocktails meet culinary artistry. The atmosphere was vibrant yet relaxed, aided by a soundtrack that perfectly complemented the evening. The staff greeted me with friendly smiles, exuding an enthusiasm that made me feel right at home.

Now, let’s talk about the old fashioned. From the very first sip, I was greeted with a harmonious blend of smooth bourbon, a touch of sweetness, and that essential hint of bitters. The orange twist added a refreshing zest, balancing the drink exquisitely. This wasn’t just any old fashioned; it was a carefully crafted masterpiece that danced across my palate.

I was also impressed by the clean, open kitchen where I could watch the culinary team work their magic. It felt reassuring to enjoy a cocktail in a place that values cleanliness and quality — both in drinks and food. The night unfolded with delicious bites that matched the drink's sophistication, enhancing the overall experience.

In the vibrant cocktail scene of Portland, Wilder stands out, not just for its old fashioned but for the entire package — great atmosphere, attentive service, and delightful flavors. It's a must-visit for anyone seeking the perfect old fashioned!

You might also want to check out the best used car dealerships in Portland.

Vintage Cocktail Lounge

Vintage Cocktail Lounge is a hidden gem that effortlessly blends nostalgia with elegance. The moment I stepped inside, I was transported back in time, surrounded by plush velvet and dim lighting—a perfect prelude to the cocktail experience. Their Old Fashioned was masterfully crafted, with just the right balance of smoky bourbon and aromatic bitters, complemented by a twist of orange that added a delightful brightness. The attention to detail sets this drink apart, showcasing the bar's dedication to craftsmanship. If you're seeking a timeless classic in a charming setting, Vintage is a must-visit for any cocktail enthusiast!

You might also want to check out the best jewelry stores in Portland.

Holy Ghost

As I sipped the old fashioned at Holy Ghost, I was immediately enchanted by its delicate balance of flavors. The bourbon provided a smooth foundation, while the house-made bitters added a delightful complexity that made each sip a joy. The citrus twist topped it off, infusing a refreshing brightness. The ambiance—a blend of vintage charm and modern flair—perfectly complemented the cocktail in my hand. I couldn't help but appreciate the craftsmanship involved; it was clear that this establishment takes its cocktails seriously. If you seek a memorable take on this classic drink, Holy Ghost is a must-visit destination in Portland!

You might also want to check out the best views in Portland.

Pope House Bourbon Lounge

Nestled in the heart of Portland, Pope House Bourbon Lounge captivated me with its inviting ambiance and bourbon-centric charm. Their Old Fashioned, crafted with precision, boasts a sublime balance of bitters, sugary sweetness, and a generous pour of whiskey. The addition of house-made bitters created a delightful complexity that danced on my palate. I couldn’t help but appreciate the elegance of the orange twist, adding a vibrant zest to this timeless classic. With its cozy vibe and knowledgeable staff, this gem is a must-visit for anyone seeking a truly exceptional old fashioned experience. Cheers!

You might also want to check out the best florists in Portland.

Hale Pele

Hale Pele is a hidden gem that blends tiki vibes with classic cocktail craftsmanship. As I sipped their take on the old fashioned, I was delighted by the rich notes of aged bourbon intertwined with a hint of tropical bitters, all garnished with a twist of orange. The ambiance is vibrant yet cozy, inviting patrons to unwind while enjoying their drinks. I appreciated the bartender’s attention to detail, showcasing the cocktail's bold flavors. If you're seeking an old fashioned with a unique spin, Hale Pele is a must-visit destination that proves classic cocktails can be both inventive and comforting.

You might also want to check out the best car wash in Portland.

Raven's Manor

Nestled in the heart of Portland, Raven's Manor serves up a playful twist on the classic old fashioned. The first sip reveals a perfectly balanced blend of smooth bourbon and aromatic bitters, while a dash of house-made cherry syrup adds a delightful sweetness. Garnished with a twist of orange peel, each drink is a work of art. The ambiance is cozy, with whimsical decor that complements the craft cocktails. If you’re seeking a unique spin on this timeless drink, Raven's Manor is sure to impress even the most discerning of palates. Cheers to the perfect pour!

You might also want to check out the best bookstore in Portland.

Teardrop Lounge

Stepping into Teardrop Lounge felt like entering a cocktail lover's paradise. The Old Fashioned here is a delightful twist on the classic—infused with just the right amount of smoky bitters that dance on the palate. Each sip reveals a symphony of flavors, showcasing top-notch bourbon and artisanal sugar. The bartenders are true alchemists, meticulously crafting each drink with a playful flair. The ambiance? Chic yet cozy, making it the perfect backdrop for savoring this timeless cocktail. If you're in Portland and yearn for an exceptional old fashioned, Teardrop is an absolute must-visit for an unforgettable experience.

You might also want to check out the best auto body shop in Portland.